Historic brick townhouse entrance with a dark paneled door, cream wood trim, worn stone steps and a camellia beside the brick approach.

The Civic Center Is Shrinking to Its Theatre, and the Holiday Shows Go On Beside the Fence

October 22, 2026

On August 20, Mayor Van R. Johnson II and City Manager Jay Melder pulled a single brick from the wall of the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Arena. It went to the City's Office of Municipal Archives & History, to be kept for a future exhibit on the Civic Center's history once construction is finished. Neighbors who came to the ceremony in the parking lot off W. Oglethorpe Ave. could take a brick home too, with a certificate of authenticity. WJCL reported that each member of City Council received a chair from inside the arena.

The Civic Center is staying open, just smaller, with the theatre as what remains. The arena is coming out, the Johnny Mercer Theatre keeps its curtain times, and Council has already put in writing that the land left over should become homes, shops and restored street blocks rather than hotels. For anyone living within a few squares of Orleans Square, this holiday season is the first one played on a site that is slowly turning back into neighborhood.

Six inches between a demolition site and a ticketed show

WJCL reported that only six inches separate the arena from the Johnny Mercer Theatre. Even so, the City's March 11 announcement says the theatre, lobby, ballroom and meeting rooms "will remain open and fully operational throughout construction."

The work started inside. Council approved a $10.9 million guaranteed maximum price, and Reeves Young, LLC began on March 18 as Construction Manager at Risk, starting with fencing, site preparation, asbestos and lead abatement, and moving the theatre's kitchen and concession area. That last item matters if you're a regular. The bar and snack stand you remember may now be somewhere else in the building.

By the August ceremony the arena interior was partly dismantled. Reeves Young project superintendent Michael Million told WJCL, "We should anticipate the building coming down somewhere around the middle to the end of September is when we'll start seeing things really start shaking loose." The City expects the whole project to take about 13 months and puts completion in spring 2027.

The arena opened in 1972 and had never been through a major redevelopment before this project. Joe Shearouse Sr., who managed the facility for decades, put it plainly in words City Manager Melder read at the ceremony: "The bones were tired, the systems outdated."

Getting to a show around the fence

The City's site logistics come from its March announcement. The release says the parking closure stays in place for the whole project and that signs will direct visitors to open parking and entrances. Here's what it lays out:

  1. Part of the Civic Center parking lot is closed for construction staging and laydown, starting March 18 and lasting through the project.
  2. Construction traffic uses Liberty Street.
  3. Public parking access is from Barnard Street only. If you've always pulled in from another side, plan on Barnard.
  4. Signs on site point to open parking and entrances, so follow them on the night of the show rather than relying on habit.

The City also said that for the first several months, the closed parking lot would be the public's biggest inconvenience, more than any visible exterior demolition. Fewer spaces and one way in make the holiday nights below the ones to plan for.

The holiday lineup, and the downtown nights it shares

These dates come from the venue's live calendar at savannahcivic.com. Listings there can change, so check showtimes before you go. The last column lists the riverfront events on the same night, using the calendars from Plant Riverside District and Savannah's Waterfront.

Date At the Johnny Mercer Theatre Listed start Also downtown that day
Thu., Nov. 19 A Magical Cirque Christmas 7:00 p.m. Plant Riverside District Christmas Market opens
Wed., Nov. 25 Jersey Boys 7:30 p.m. Christmas Market running, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Sat., Nov. 28 Nutcracker by South Carolina Ballet 5:30 p.m. 25th Lighted Boat Parade at Eastern Wharf
Tue., Dec. 8 Jodeci 7:00 p.m. Christmas Market running
Sat., Dec. 12 Matthew West 7:00 p.m. 34th Lighted Christmas Street Parade; waterfront performances

The two Saturdays need the most planning. On November 28 the Nutcracker starts at 5:30 p.m., the same evening the boat parade fills Eastern Wharf. On December 12 the Matthew West concert falls on the night of the Lighted Christmas Street Parade. On either night, getting to the theatre's single Barnard Street parking entrance early is what keeps the evening on schedule. The Christmas Market at Plant Riverside is free and open daily from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. through January 3, 2027, so a weeknight dinner on the river before an early curtain takes little planning.

What the ground held before the arena

All of this matters because the arena itself was the exception on these blocks. According to the City's history of the site, the land has been rebuilt several times:

  • Early 1800s. Land first set aside as part of the Town Common is laid out as Elbert and Jackson wards.
  • 1819. The Bulloch House, designed by British architect William Jay, goes up on the Trust Lots facing Orleans Square.
  • About a century later. The house is torn down for the Municipal Auditorium, which faced the square and hosted plays, concerts and recitals. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. spoke to Savannahians from its stage.
  • 1971 to 1972. The Auditorium is demolished, and the new Savannah Civic Center opens in early 1972 with an arena, theatre and ballroom.
  • July 1984. At the request of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, City Council names the arena for Dr. King, recognizing the link to his Auditorium address 20 years earlier.
  • December 11, 2025. Council renames the whole Civic Center in Dr. King's honor, so his name stays on the site after the arena is gone.

The 1972 building replaced ward blocks with one large footprint, and the redevelopment documents describe undoing that.

What Council wrote down for the land

The guiding document is a resolution on the June 27, 2024 City Council agenda, titled "Removal of the Arena and Renovation of the Theatre, Ballroom, and Community Meeting Rooms." These priorities are quoted from the resolution text.

"Restores as much of the Oglethorpe Plan as feasible." "Prioritizes housing, including affordable and workforce housing." "Prohibits the development of new hotels and restricts the use of short-term vacation rentals." "Optimizes space for public and municipal use, as well as appropriate retail and commercial spaces."

The same resolution keeps the name and legacy of Dr. King, calls for an equitable approach to redeveloping the area, and plans for future parking needs.

The scale is starting to take shape. The Civic Center sits on about 7 acres. At the August ceremony, Mayor Johnson said four acres "will come available" and called the goal "aspirational, creating 200-300 housing units, 40-60 row homes, 45,000 square-feet of local retail space, and some public space for us to be able to use again." Those are targets, not an approved site plan.

Savannah Agenda reported that on July 14 the City issued a request for proposals for an owner's representative to manage the program. That role may later help with developer solicitations. The City's solicitation expects the street grid to be restored and the trust and tithing lots redeveloped in phases from 2027 through 2031, and it leaves room for that approach to change. Whether Elbert Square itself returns is still open. Council's written commitment is to restore "as much of the Oglethorpe Plan as feasible."

For the near future, that means a theatre on one side of the fence and a demolition site on the other. Shows run through December while crews take apart a 1972 building on land that held ward blocks for well over a century before it. The brick in the City archives is waiting for an exhibit, and the City has tied that exhibit to the project's completion.

Changes on a block like this one shape how buyers and owners see the streets around Orleans Square long before the first new row home goes up. If you'd like to talk about how the Civic Center plans could affect your corner of the Historic District, Liza DiMarco is happy to walk through it with you. Let's Connect.

Work With Liza

Navigate the intricacies of real estate negotiations with confidence. Liza's unparalleled negotiation skills have consistently delivered optimal outcomes for her clients. Trust in her ability to secure the best deals, whether you're buying or selling.